Is This for Me?

Been Told You May Need a Knee Replacement?

This visit is for you if another doctor has said you may need your first knee replacement, or you simply want to compare your treatment options before deciding. Dr. Pallitto, a fellowship-trained hip and knee replacement surgeon, will give you an independent look at your knee and an honest recommendation.

Already had a knee replacement that isn't feeling right? See Revision Hip & Knee Replacement Second Opinion instead.

How Do I Book?

Call to Book a New-Patient Second Opinion

Call the office nearest you and ask for a knee replacement second opinion with Dr. Pallitto. No referral is typically needed.

Hilton Head Island (843) 681-2363 Bluffton (843) 837-4300 Beaufort (843) 525-0045
What Will Dr. Pallitto Assess?
  • Your symptoms and how they affect daily life
  • A hands-on examination of your knee, its alignment, and your hip
  • Your X-rays and any other imaging
  • Treatments you've already tried
  • Your procedure options, surgical and nonsurgical
  • Your recovery and activity goals
Am I Committing to Surgery?

No.

A second opinion is a consultation, not a commitment. You'll leave with a clear recommendation — which may be surgery, nonsurgical treatment, or waiting — and the decision stays yours. You're free to have surgery with your original surgeon, with Dr. Pallitto, or not at all.

What Should I Bring?

If you have them, bring prior X-rays or MRI images and their reports, notes from the doctor who recommended surgery, and a list of treatments you've tried and medications you take.

Don't have them? When you call, tell us where your imaging was done and our office can help request the images and reports. If current X-rays are needed, they can often be taken at your visit.

Why Patients Ask for a Second Opinion

Common Reasons for a Second Look

  • You were told you need a knee replacement and want that confirmed before you commit
  • You're unsure whether now is the right time, or whether it can reasonably wait
  • You'd like to know if nonsurgical options have been fully explored
  • You want to know whether a partial knee replacement could be an option
  • You have questions about robotic-assisted knee replacement
  • You've moved to the Lowcountry and want a local surgeon's independent read

What a Second Opinion Can Clarify

  • Whether your pain is truly coming from the knee — hip problems can cause pain felt in the knee
  • Whether your X-rays match how much your symptoms limit you
  • Whether a partial or total knee replacement fits your pattern of arthritis
  • What surgery and recovery would realistically look like for you

Options We May Discuss

Your Knee Treatment Options

Nonsurgical Treatment

Physical therapy, bracing, activity changes, medication, and injections can control symptoms for some patients and delay or avoid surgery.

Nonoperative Options →

Total or Partial Knee Replacement

Total knee replacement resurfaces the whole joint. When arthritis is limited to one part of the knee, a partial (unicompartmental) replacement may be an option.

About Knee Replacement →

Robotic-Assisted Surgery

Dr. Pallitto uses MAKO SmartRobotics™ and VELYS™ robotic-assisted technology to plan and perform knee replacement around your anatomy.

About Robotic Surgery →

What to Expect

Your Second-Opinion Visit

1

Your Story & Records

Dr. Pallitto reviews your symptoms, the treatments you've tried, and any records and imaging from your prior evaluation.

2

Current X-Rays, If Needed

If your imaging is missing or out of date, new X-rays can often be taken on-site to show how your knee looks today.

3

Examination & Discussion

Dr. Pallitto examines your knee, talks through your goals, and explains what the exam and imaging show in plain language.

4

A Clear Recommendation

You'll leave knowing your options and Dr. Pallitto's recommendation — whether that's surgery now, nonsurgical treatment, or checking back later.

Good to Know

Frequently Asked Questions

Will getting a second opinion upset my current surgeon?

Second opinions are a normal part of planning an elective surgery like joint replacement, and surgeons are used to them. You don't need your current surgeon's permission to get one.

Could a partial knee replacement be an option for me?

Possibly. Partial (unicompartmental) knee replacement may be an option when arthritis is limited to one part of the knee. Whether it fits depends on your imaging, exam, and knee stability, which Dr. Pallitto will review with you.

What if Dr. Pallitto agrees with my first recommendation?

Then you can move forward with more confidence. You're free to have surgery with your original surgeon or, if you prefer, with Dr. Pallitto.

What if I'm not ready for surgery?

That's fine. If your symptoms can be managed without surgery for now, Dr. Pallitto will say so directly and outline what to try and when to check back.

Do I need a referral?

Typically no referral is required. If your insurance plan requires one, our office can help you understand the process when you call.

Is a second opinion covered by insurance?

Second-opinion consultations are commonly covered by insurance plans. Our office can help you verify your specific benefits before your visit.

Where We Practice

Hilton Head, Bluffton & Beaufort

Hilton Head Island

Phone
(843) 681-2363
View Details

Book Your Knee Replacement Second Opinion

Call the office nearest you and ask for a new-patient second opinion with Dr. Pallitto.

Hilton Head Island (843) 681-2363 Bluffton (843) 837-4300 Beaufort (843) 525-0045